American Flags of
Independence:
Please to fix upon some
particular Colour for a flag - & a Signal, by which our Vessels
may know one another. .. Col.
Joseph Reed, Military Secretary to General George Washington,
1775.
1. Grand Union Flag/Continental Colors, January 1, 1776:
A design of thirteen stripes, alternately red and white, with
a blue field in the upper-left-hand corner bearing the red cross
of St. George of England with the white cross of St. Andrew of
Scotland. The "colonies" sought to govern themselves
or at least have a greater control of the local government and
still remain a participant in the United Kingdom. The purpose
was one of reconciliation of differences. The union of the flag
represented Great Britain and the 13 stripes represented the united
colonies in Northern America. <H-11>
RESOLVED: that the flag of the United States be thirteen
stripes, alternate red and white; that the Union be thirteen stars,
white in a blue field representing a new constellation.
.. Act of the Continental Congress, June 14, 1777.
2. American Revolution "Mullet" (5 vs. 6 point) June 14, 1777: The British crosses were probably dropped to indicate no hope of reconciliation under the Crown. Francis Hopkinson, not Betsy Ross, probably made the first Stars & Stripes banner. He was on the Naval Board and had a keen interest in heraldry. "The five-pointed star as a political symbol originated during the American Revolution. In the Old World the icon that resembles such a star was an insignificant emblem that British and French heraldry labeled a "mullet." This symbol does not connote a star of the heavens but is rather a schematic representation of the rowel of a spur, which in heraldry adored the arms of the third-born son in a noble family. The celestial star is the "estoile," with six wavy points, which by the seventeenth century had become a common charge in heraldry. Before its incorporation into the U. S. flag, the five-point star was rare on flags or other heraldic devices." "Having little regard for Old World formalities, colonial Americans opted to represent the heavenly star with five points rather than the more proper six points of the estoile." <H-11><M-20>
3. National Flag, 1818:
The practice of adding a star and a stripe for each new state
after the original proved too cumbersome
and in 1818 Congress reverted back to the original thirteen stripes
and added a star for each new state, on the July 4th following
admission. Until 1912 the arrangement of the stars was left to
the flag maker. <H-222>
Mexican Flags of Independence:
1. Virgin of Guadalupe, 1810: Father Miguel Hidalgo & Costilla, a priest who is credited with beginning the Mexican revolution for independence on September 16, 1810 with his declaration called the Grito de Delores. His followers rallied behind a simple church banner with the Virgin of Guadalupe image. The image reminded Father Hidalgo's followers of the important role their ancestors had played in their country's history. [Angel with wings of green, white and red was part of the image] Within a year the rally was put down. <M-4>
2. Flag of the Three Guarantees',
1821: Augustin de Iturbide negotiated the Plan de Iguala with
rebel Vincente Guerrero
on February 24, 1821 for Mexico to become a "Constitutional
Monarchy." Iturbide offered a new flag that embodied the
tenets of the Three Guarantees (1. Primacy of the Catholic Church,
2. Independence and 3. Equality of Gachupines and native-born
Mexicans). The flag was designed by Jose Ocampo, a tailor. It
was a square flag with three diagonal bars of red, green &
white. This was changed in November 1821 to three vertical bars
rearranged to green, white & red. "A crowned eagle with
open wings perching on a cactus replaced the crown." Iturbide
was crowned emperor of Mexico on July 21, 1822 and shortly afterwards
disbanded the congress. <M-6>
3. Mexican National Flag April 1823: Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna led the revolt that overthrew Iturbide early in 1823 (Plan of Casa Mata) and Mexico became a Republic. "To represent the republic, the imperial crown was removed from the eagle, and the figure of a snake was added. As the traditional symbols of strength and victory, branches of laurel and oak now wreathed the base of the cactus." In 1916 the eagle symbol was changed to the "Aztec Eagle" which is the image in use today. <M-7, 8, 167n.20>
Texas Flags of Independence:
I. Evolution of the "Lone Star" symbol
1. West Florida Republic Flag,
September 26, 1810: "The Louisiana Purchase of 1803 had left
the territory of West
Florida - the area between the Pearl and the Mississippi Rivers
- in Spanish control." In September 1810, group of settlers
seized control, declared themselves a republic and offered themselves
for immediate annexation to the United States. President James
Madison obliged. "Thus, early nineteenth century Americans
adopted the five-point star as a symbol of 'enlightened revolution
against old-word monarchies - a moral crusade for the rights of
man'."<M-21>
2. Long's Expedition Flag, June 1818: The Adams-Onis Treaty of 1819 confirmed that Texas was a part of Spanish Mexico. Some lower South citizens thought it belonged to the United States and organized an army under the command of Dr. James Long. The arrived in Nacogdoches and declared the province independent from Spain with the intention of delivering it to the United States. They flew a silk lone-star flag. The Spanish authorities quickly drove the filibusters back across the Sabine. <M-21>
II. Mexican State Flags:
1. Coahuila y Tejas State Flag: Based upon a militia flag from Nacogdoches required in 1828, it is assumed that the Mexican eagle adorned the flag like the National Flag and the name of the state was added at the top. <DP>
2.. Revised Coahuila y Texas Flag (double star). Texas was a province affiliated with Coahuila (a double state). Capital was at Saltillo until moved to Monclova on March 9, 1833. Flag made with two stars in vertical position replacing the eagle motif. Coahuila and Texas were joined as one state in 1825. Almonte said it was flown at the Alamo when Santa Anna arrived. Also shown in a sketch by Sanchez-Navarro during the siege. Assume the six pointed stars were used since it was in the Mexican tradition. To use a five-pointed star would indicate U. S. interests above Mexican. Some authors show the five pointed star and it is known that the five pointed star was used on private coinage in Bexar in 1818. <Veazy-6> <A-162> <M-12> <DP>
In April, 1833 Texas suggested its desire to become a separate state instead of a "double-state" with Coahuila. Sam Houston chaired the committee that drafted the sample state constitution. Stephen F. Austin took it to Mexico City to present to the newly elected President Santa Anna. In the meantime Santa Anna had turned running of the country over to his vice-president Gomez Farias. Farias denied Austin's request. Austin wrote a letter back to Texas saying they should begin setting up a separate government even though he lacked the approval to due such. Then Santa Anna returned and Austin again made his plea, and although he was offered encouragement, the separation was not forthcoming. In December 1833 Austin was on his way back to Texas when he was arrested in Saltillo. The arrest was based upon his earlier letter and Austin was returned to Mexico City and put in jail. While Farias was acting President, his federalist reforms were not popular with the Church and the military. Santa Anna again returned in April 1834 and this time exiled Farias. By October 1835 Santa Anna had reversed his political philosophy, seized dictatorial powers and a centralist government replaced the existing federalist form. Centralist were considered conservatives since the favored the old Spanish form of government which combined Church and State and favored the military. The Federalist were the liberals as they believed in sharing power between the national and the state governments and did not support favortism to the Church and the military. <A-184, 185>
Some were for independence;
some for the constitution of 1824; and some for anything, just
so it was a row(e)
.Noah
Smithwick
III. Battle Flags:
1. Scott's "Independence" Flag, mid-Sept. 1835: The local committee of vigilance and safety sent out a call to arms on about September 19, 1835 in response to news that Gen. Cos planned an invasion of Texas. About 30 men responded to the call in Lynchburg and were fully equipped by William Scott. He decided a flag should be made. Charles Lanco, with the assistance of Mrs. Joseph Lynch at Lynchburg made the flag (probably before Dodson's flag) . "Four yards of blue silk donated by Scott with a painted white star and the word "Independence." James L. McGahey took the flag to the battle of Concepcion (Oct. 28th) (but had put in his nap sack at San Felipe so it might not have flown), where he gave it to Thomas B. Bell, who flew it at the Grass Fight (Nov. 26) and perhaps in the (final stage of the) Siege of Bexar." <M-24> <NHBTxOL-Flags><SWHQ:18-271>
2. Dodson's "Lone Star" flag, mid-Sept: 1835. Also responding to the September 19, 1835 call for volunteers, Capt. Andrew Robinson, Jr. raised a company from the community of Harrisburg . Made by Sarah Dodson for her husband, Lt. Archelaus Bynum Dodson for his volunteer company. Made of calico (cotton), blue, red and white squares of equal sizes. "The white star allegedly symbolized that Texas was the only Mexican state in which the star of liberty was rising." Carried at least as far as Cibolo Creek by James Ferguson and possibly at the Battle of Concepcion and the Siege of Bexar. However, Austin had asked him not to fly it at Bexar for fear that it would be considered a revolutionary flag. Probably made after Scott's flag. At Washington on March 2 (Declaration of Independence), one of two flags. Considered the first Tri-Color Lone Star flag. <V-7><NHBTxOL-Flags>< SWHQ:18-273, 274><M-24>
3. Come & Take It,
Oct. 2, 1835: First flag of the revolution to see action. Designed
and painted by Cynthia Burns and Evaline
DeWitt. Two descriptions (Smithwick: "white cotton cloth
about six fee long, in the center of which was painted in black
a picture of the old cannon, above it a lone star and beneath
it the words 'Come and Take it.'" Charles Mason: "a
white ground with a black cannon in the center, and the motto
'Come and take it!' above and below.") Left Gonzales on Oct.
13. Flag left along the road to Bexar with the broken cannon (carriage).
<SW-72><NHBTxOL-Flags> <M-23>
4. Dimmit's "Constitution of 1824" flag, October 18, 1835: Made by Philip Dimmit, commander of the fort at Goliad. On October 27th he wrote Stephen F. Austin saying "I have had a flag made - the colours, and their arrangement the same as the old one - with the words and figures, 'Constitution of 24' displayed on the white, in the center." This flag was an expression of the "peace party" that desired a return to the Constitution of 1824 which supported a federalist government and certain rights to the states and their citizen. Santa Anna had suspended the constitution when he declared himself dictator and returned to the old Centralist form of government favored by the Church and the military. On December 6th Dimmit took his flag to Bexar to participate in the final assault. General Cos surrendered on Dec. 9th. The flag was left in Bexar since Dimmit changed his politics about the struggle while in Bexar. The time for talk was over, separation and independence was the only course of action. Grant and Johnson, still seeking reconciliation, each lead a company carrying an "1824" flag (don't know if "Constitution of" was included) after leaving the Alamo and beginning on the Matamoros Expedition. Meanwhile, Dimmit returned to Goliad and designed another flag, this one for independence. <DP> <Y>
5. New Orleans Grays, October: Organized in New Orleans on October 13. Two companies were formed. The first under the command of Capt. Thomas H. Breece and the second under Capt. Robert C. Morris. They left New Orleans with in two days of each other, bound for Texas. Breece took the northern route, overland route and entered Texas over Gaines' Ferry. Morris and 68 men sailed and arrived at Velasco on October 22nd. Breece's company was given a flag "by a group of East Texas ladies." It is a blue silk banner displaying an eagle and sunburst with the inscription "First Company of Texan Volunteers! From New Orleans". The eagle carries in its beak a banner with the motto "God & Liberty." Breece took the flag to the Siege of Bexar, arriving after Morris' company. After the fall of Bexar, all but 23 of the combined companies left with James Grant and F. W. Johnson on the Matamoros Expedition but most then chose to stay with the garrison at Goliad. The Grays flag was left at San Antonio with the remaining Grays and all perished at the fall of the Alamo. Santa Anna captured the flag and sent it as a trophy flag back to Mexico after the fall of the Alamo. The only flag still in existence that flew over the Alamo. Santa Anna reports that there were more than one flag at the Alamo. <NHBTx: 2-1023> <NHBTxOL-Flags><NHBTx: 4-998><M-10, 27>
6. Troutman "Lone Star" flag, also known as the Ward's Georgia Battalion flag. Late November: Johanna Troutman made the flag in November 1835 in Georgia. White silk displaying a blue embroidered lone star and the words "Liberty or Death" on one side and on the reverse the motto "Ubi Libertas Habitat, Ibi Nostra Patria Est" (where liberty resides, there is our homeland). Five-point star appliquéd on each side. Presented to William Ward's Georgia Battalion. November 1835 (well after the 12th) in Crawford County, Georgia. Carried to Texas and unfurled at Velasco on January 8, 1836 (anniversary of the Battle of New Orleans) over the American Hotel. Carried to Goliad where Fannin raised it on March 8 at Goliad to celebrate the news of the Texas Declaration of Independence. Destroyed by high winds at Goliad that evening. Selected on Feb. 25, 1913 over Sara Dodson as "the designer of the Lone Star flag of Texas" by both houses of the Texas Legislature. <V-10> <NHBTxOL-Flags> <M- ><Vinson-113>
7. Alabama's Red Rover flag, late November: Company of 75 volunteers raised and equipped by Dr. John Schackford of Courtland, Alabama, arrived in Jan. 1836. Called the Red Rovers because its members were uniformed in red jeans. Small, square, red battle flag reportedly captured at Goliad and taken to Mexico City. Most were killed at Goliad. <Gilbert-64> <NHBTxOL-Flags>
8. General Council's "1824" privateer flag, Nov. 29, 1835. First official flag of the Revolution. General Council adopted the "1824" flag which was a modification of Philip Dimmit's flag of Oct. 27th. Using the Mexican National Flag, the tri-color of green, white and red panels, the Mexican Eagle was replaced with the numbers (representing the date of) 1824. The official flag was approved for flying by privateers operating under Letters of Marquee and Reprisal as late as Feb. 1836. Dr. Grant & F. W. Johnson each flew a 1824 flag on their illfated Matamoros Expedition. Popular myth holds that this flag flew at the Alamo when it fell on March 6, 1836. It was neither captured or reported in official journals. <Yates>
9. Dimmit's "Bloody Arm" flag, Dec. 20, 1835: When Dimmit returned from the Siege of Bexar where he flew his "Constitution of 1824" flag, his politics had changed from the conservative to the independence cause. Philip Dimmitt raised this new flag at Goliad on Dec. 20, 1835, on the occasion of the Goliad Declaration of Independence. Made of white cotton domestic two yards long, one yard wide and in the center was painted with red ink or dye, an arm and hand holding aloft a drawn sword. Dimmit remained as commander of Goliad until removed Jan. 10 and the flag was taken down. Dimmit was Alamo army storekeeper from Jan 24 to February 24. He arrived at San Jacinto with recruits and supplies on April 22nd. <NHBTxOL-Flags><NHBTx: 1-516> <DP>
10. Sidney Sherman's "San Jacinto" flag, late Dec. Brought to Texas by Sidney Sherman organized a company of 52 volunteers in Kentucky. Allegedly painted by James H. Beard and presented to the Newport (Kentucky Rifle Company by Sherman's wife Katherine Sherman. "The flag is made of white silk with the painted figure of a partially bare-breasted woman grasping in one hand a sword over which is draped a streamer with the words "Liberty or Death". Probably based on Eugene Delacroix's painting "Liberty Leading the People." The lady in the flag representing liberty. Originally the (background) field was blue. The company left Kentucky on Dec. 31 (but military service credited from Dec. 18). Not sure when they arrived in Texas. The only surviving flags of the Texas Revolution are the Red Rover flag, the New Orleans Greys flag and the San Jacinto flag. The former two are held in Mexico as spoils of war and the San Jacinto flag is in Austin. <NHBTxOL-Flags> <NHBTx:5-1020><M-26>
11. Brown's "Bloody Arm" flag, Flag created by William S. Brown of Velasco. Flown possibly as early as Dec. 1835 at the Siege of Bexar by no collateral documentation. Flown at Velasco on Jan. 8, 1836 at the American Hotel with the Troutman flag. William S. Brown of Velasco. The flag consisted of thirteen alternating red & white horizontal stripes and a blue union. The word "Independence" was written on one white stripe (3rd from the top, of six) and a sinewy arm and hand grasping a bloody sword in the oversized (long) union.. One source says the flag was flown at the Convention when Independence was declared on March 2nd, along with the Dodson flag. However, Brown was made captain of the schooner Liberty in January 1836, and continued to serve until relieved of duty March 12. Do not know who would have taken the flag to Washington. <V-9> <NHBTxOL-Flags>
(Santa Anna's Alamo Red Flag: Feb. 23, 1836) Santa Anna's Flag raised over the tower of San Fernando de Bexar Church as a sign of no quarter. <NHBTxOL-Flags>
12. Baker's "San Felipe" flag, Feb. 29, 1836. Flag presented Feb. 29, 1936 to the volunteer company from San Felipe under the leadership of Capt. Moseley Baker. Presented by Gail Borden, Jr. Based upon the design of a flag by Stephen F. Austin described in a letter to Borden. Thought to have been made by Pamela Shelpherd and Nina Stewart in Shelpherd's house at San Felipe.. to Baker at San Felipe on March 2. The English Jack designated the origin of the Anglo-Americans; thirteen stripes represented that most of the Texan Colonist were from the US, the tri-color of red, white & green indicated that at one time Texas was a part of the Mexican confederation and the white, five pointed star stood for Texas herself - only state in Mexico claiming the light of Liberty. Baker marched his men to Gonzales and joined Sam Houston's army there. The San Felipe Volunteers remained a unit during the retreat and participated, under Baker, at the Battle of San Jacinto on April 21, 1836. Unfortunately the flag disappeared along the way and Baker substituted a red handkerchief for his company's flag at San Jacinto (see below). <dp> <NHBTxOL-Flags> <Cox-178>
13. National "Naval" flag, April 9. A National flag for naval service adopted April 9, 1836 at Harrisburg as the Interim government was in retreat. Flown before San Jacinto. Made at the home of Mrs. Jane Harris by the ladies of Harrisburg. It had a "union blue, star central, thirteen stripes prolonged, alternate red and white." Burnet felt that the Navy flag then in use (1824, see above) was confusing and would be mistaken for a Mexican vessel, so he had this flag designed to be clearly seen as not Mexican, and in fact, deceptive in its confusion with the U. S. Flag at a distance. <SWHQ:59-488>
14. Baker's "Red" flag at San Jacinto, April 21: Carried at San Jacinto on April 21, 1836 by Baker's company (obviously lost the San Felipe flag, see above). It was a red handkerchief . It was carried until the battle commenced and was dropped and lost. <SWHQ:45-45>
Flags at San Jacinto:
1. Sidney Sherman's "San Jacinto" flag, late Dec. Brought to Texas by Sidney Sherman organized a company of 52 volunteers in Kentucky. Allegedly painted by James H. Beard and presented to the Newport (Kentucky Rifle Company by Sherman's wife Katherine Sherman. "The flag is made of white silk with the painted figure of a partially bare-breasted woman grasping in one hand a sword over which is draped a streamer with the words "Liberty or Death". Probably based on Eugene Delacroix's painting "Liberty Leading the People." The lady in the flag representing liberty. Originally the (background) field was blue. The company left Kentucky on Dec. 31 (but military service credited from Dec. 18). Not sure when they arrived in Texas. The only surviving flags of the Texas Revolution are the Red Rover flag, the New Orleans Greys flag and the San Jacinto flag. The former two are held in Mexico as spoils of war and the San Jacinto flag is in Austin. <NHBTxOL-Flags> <NHBTx:5-1020><M-26>
2. Baker's "Red" flag : Carried at San Jacinto on April 21, 1836 by Baker's company (obviously lost the San Felipe flag). It was a red handkerchief . It was carried until the battle commenced and was dropped and lost. <SWHQ:45-45>
3. Permanent Guerrero Battalion: Arrived with the Mexican General Cos on the morning of April 21. 58" on the hoist by 60" on the fly. Located at the Texas State Archives.
4. Permanent Matamoros Battalion: Arrived at Bexar on February 23 with 272 veteran assault soldiers. Participated in the Zacatecas campaign the previous May. Marched with Santa Anna from Fort Bend. Commander Col. Jose Maria Romero captured at San Jacinto. 57" on the hoist by 67" on the fly. Located at the Texas State Archives.
5. Active Toluca Battalion: Arrived at Bexar on March 3rd with 324 veteran assault troops. Participated in the Zacatecas Campaign in previous May. Suffered heavy casualties in the assault on the Alamo. Only 130 survived. Arrived with General Cos in the morning of April 21. 68" on the hoist by 54" on the fly. Currently under restoration. On loan to the San Jacinto Museum.
6. Santa Anna's "Guard" flag. Carried by the 50 Escort Dragoons from the Permanent Tampico Regiment and the Guanajuato Territorial Regiment. These Regiments participated previously in the Goliad Campaign. Arrived with Santa Anna from Fort Bend. Unknown dimensions. Color enhanced. Located at the Dallas Historical Society.
Flags of the Republic:
1. General Council's "1824" naval flag, Nov. 29, 1835. First official flag of the Revolution. General Council adopted the "1824" flag which was a modification of Philip Dimmit's flag of Oct. 27th. Using the Mexican National Flag, the tri-color of green, white and red panels, the Mexican Eagle was replaced with the numbers (representing the date of) 1824. The official flag was approved for flying by privateers operating under Letters of Marquee and Reprisal as late as Feb. 1836. Dr. Grant & F. W. Johnson each flew a 1824 flag on their illfated Matamoros Expedition. Popular myth holds that this flag flew at the Alamo when it fell on March 6, 1836. It was neither captured or reported in official journals. <Yates>
2. DeZavala's Flag, March
11, 1836, but no evidence it ever flown. DeZavala's Flag adopted
as the first Official flag
of the Republic on March 11, 1836.
However, no evidence that it was ever flown. Amended by William
B. Scates on March 12 added a "rainbow and star of five points
above the western horizon; and the star of six points sinking
below." <SWHQ:59-487>
3. "National flag for Naval Service", April 9, 1836. A National flag for naval service adopted April 9, 1836 at Harrisburg as the Interim government was in retreat. Flown before San Jacinto. Made at the home of Mrs. Jane Harris by the ladies of Harrisburg. It had a "union blue, star central, thirteen stripes prolonged, alternate red and white." Burnet felt that the Navy flag then in use (1824, see above) was confusing and would be mistaken for a Mexican vessel, so he had this flag designed to be clearly seen as not Mexican, and in fact, deceptive in its confusion with the U. S. Flag at a distance. <SWHQ:59-488>
4. Burnet's flag, "National Standard" Dec. 10, 1836. Burnet's Official flag December 10, 1836. "Azure ground, with a large golden star central." <SWHQ:59-489>
5. Stewart's "National flag", Jan. 25, 1839: Dr. George B. Stewart's flag designated official flag of the Republic on 1839. January 25, 1836 by act of congress as the national Standard. Bill submitted by Senator Jones. Flag drawn by P. Krag, an artist, and used as exhibit to the bill. <SWHQ:59-490> Subsequently adopted as the State flag of Texas after it joined the Union. <L-Art.6139a>
Flags at the time of Statehood:
1. United States, 27 stars U. S. legislature approved annexation of Texas on December 29, 1845. Texas joined the Union February 19, 1846 as the 28th state. The first U. S. flag had 27 stars and the 28th star for Texas was added July 4, 1946. <Smithsonian letter> When the state flag is displayed on a staff, the staff should be at least 2 ½ times as long as the flag's hoist, and the state flag should be attached to the staff's peak. The staff's finial should be either a lone star or a spearhead. <L-Art.6139a>
2. United States, 28 stars
a. version 1
Bibliography:
<A> Texas Almanac, 1986-87, Dallas, Dallas Morning News, 1986
<C> Cox, Mamie Wynne, The Romantic Flags of Texas, Dallas, Banks Upshaw & Company, 1936. (T929.9 C 877, TX M, HPL)
<DP> Observations by David Pomeroy
<H> Hinrichs, Kit & Delphine, Long May She Wave, Berkeley, Ten Speed Press, (2002).
<L> Vernon's Texas Civil Statutes
<M> Mayberry, Robert Jr, Texas Flags, College Station, Texas A & M University Press, 2001.
<N> New Handbook of Texas (generally)
<Q> Southwestern Historical Quarterly (generally)
<S> E-mail from Smithsonian,
July 31, 1998, in author's possession.
<SW> Smithwick, Noah, Evolution of a State, Austin, University
of Texas Press, 1990
<V> Veazey, Steve & Potter, John D. Jr. Flags in the History of Texas, Dallas, Hendrick-Long Publishing Co., 1991
<Y> Yates, Charles
Return to Flag Home Page
3.28.04
.