Official Url: hk-usa.com . Hickok45 discusses and compares the HK VP9 and the Sig P320. This is admittedly subjective, but it seemed like it took longer for it to come out of recoil, negating some of the awesomeness of that trigger. Out of all the striker fired handguns on the market, I think the VP9 is one of the best in terms of comfort and ergonomics. I have a vp9 and i am so happy with it, is my carry and my home defense? How do they shoot: Recoil? Trigger: Striker-Fired. Continue reading. HK has been really good to LE and Military contractholders. Some experts disagree. Results. The SIG P320 is well-known among carriers for its versatility and modular design. That trigger was like nothing at all. Sig says its gun is safe. … Feel Free to leave any questions regarding these two handguns and when I do my full review I will try to answer as many questions as possible. So is it better than my Glock 17? SiG P320 Pros: You may really like the modularity. It will reward experimentation. I’m a cool, badass CTU agent. You can get bigger or smaller controls for the mag release and the slide release to fit your preference. I own both and I shoot the p320 better than the vp9. I prefer the VP9. The VP9 had the best groups at 21 feet with about 2 inches total diameter with 30 rounds, versus 2.5 inches with the full size P320, 3 inches with the compact P320 and 3 inches with the P2000SK. HK VP9 Pros: Amazing ergonomics. More is better. P320 comes in second, with a longer sight radius and heavier slide, edging out the PPQ with its great trigger. Cons: Walther has atrocious market penetration. Being a lefty, the vp9 is totally ambidextrous. I shot it best, I like it’s trigger for anything I might choose to do with it (including carry and competition), the ergonomics are great, and it shoots well. I've been shooting HKs for quite some time, and have quite a few rounds through my P30L and VP9, and the Sig really was a close 2nd that it was tough to call it really a loss for my first time shooting it. You’ll love the VP9. Marginally smaller than the VP9, quite a bit smaller than the P320 full size (this was what I had to rent). The P320 has a lot of haters, but it is a nice striker fired pistol, in the carry or full size with the X grip module instead of the standard grip modules. June 17, 2020 7:00:00 AM PDT ... the CZ 75 Compact or PCR, the Sig P320 Compact and so on, so forth, ad infinitum. Compare the dimensions and specs of Heckler & Koch VP9 and Sig Sauer P320 XCompact. So…just buy a new gun, and have more guns. Recently shot the sig … Not bad, but they’ve managed to make a 9mm feel .40-like in a handgun that isn’t a mousegun. The trigger was very good. First gun XDM 9 vs. HK VP9 vs Sig P320 or S&W M&P9 2.0. I could gush for hours about the grip. Have the apex trigger on my 320. I don’t know how well it will hold up, especially if you’re doing lots of swapping. Note also that the SiG only comes with the standard grip-frame module. And two more bullets is always nice. Of course then again I'd rather take the new S&W M&P 2.0 9mm handgun and put an APEX trigger kit in it, that would be a sweet setup. You may hate the paddle releases. Not exactly a bantamweight fighter, the VP9SK has roots going back to the beginning of the polymer pistol era. ), and find a good holster that I can practice with at the range. Trigger . Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more. Again, your shooting preferences will dictate your choice. You suck, and they hate you or something. Model: VP9. But that's just me. However, who the hell leaves a Glock stock? The Sig P320 - its too new to market. Go sit with the filth and buy your scum class tickets. Cons: I do not like the modularity. 2. I shoot them all about the same and I find the VP9 to be lighter, more comfortable to shoot and the HK pro trigger kit I put in it has made for a sweet trigger. The slide release is super far back, even though there’s no decocker. I like guns. Switch to Hybrid Mode. So it’s really easy to shoot fast, but felt a bit like having a P226 that I hadn’t decocked–I’m not sure if I’d want to carry it like that. The P320, on the other hand, has swappable FRAMES. Compare the dimensions and specs of Heckler & Koch VP9SK and Sig Sauer P320 XCompact Archived. For purely subjective definitions of ‘jumpy’ and ‘flippy’ of course, since I don’t have a great way to measure recoil. If you bought a new gun, you’d have more mags too. I brought about 300 rounds tonight and just did a plain white target with some 1 inch dots on it to see how each grouped, doing 2 mags in each gun (VP9 Tactical 9mm, P2000SK SA/DA 9mm, P320 full size 9mm and P320 compact 9mm). The VP9 comes with swappable backstraps in small, medium and large. SIG Sauer P320 320F9BSS9mm Luger, $579. Good luck finding ones to try in a gun shop before you buy. You’ve been waiting for it, and here it is. Also, you’ll be called an HK fanboy, so be prepared. Civilian market, not so much. RELATED STORY. The correct answer is to buy the Glock and the HK. How do the Ergonomics Compare? It’s also really short, with very little take up and a very short reset. The same can be said for the Glock by using a G 17 magazine and the G 19. Hk VP9 vs Glock 19 vs Sig p320. So, let’s get down to it. But, shut up this pistol is great. Which mag release do you like more .... button or paddle? Cons: The price. It’s like a double action pull with next to no weight. HK wins all the way. All of them have crappy magazine prices. - The Soapbox. It also feels heavier than the other two. Email this Page. I’ve never wanted to caliber-convert a 9mm to a .40 or vice versa. Click on a term to search for related topics. They really should include the low-profile one so your thumb isn’t hitting it all the time. Good morning all. I would have been much happier if they came with three magazines in the box. We cover this popular gun in our Sig P320 X5 Legion Review. It’s got some take up and a noticeable break, and didn’t feel overly light or heavy. For that sort of person, the VP9 may be better out of the box. Very good ergonomics allowing a nice, high grip. Finally, I really, really don’t like the modularity. I shoot the VP best of the two. The trigger lacks that safety blade thing, which is nice. I actually prefered it to that of the PPQ and that of the P320 as far as Things I Would Carry. The frame, magazine, and barrel are the same as the P250. The SIG P320 struck a familiar pose. But it’s probably a sweet gamer trigger. Get with the program, SiG. Heckler & Koch VP9 . Look, I don’t live in some communist hell-hole where the number of guns I can own is limited. Moderator Tools: Show Printable Version. I would get Fishbreath’s opinion too, but he doesn’t have a range with a good rental selection near him. He wants to sell me more guns. There’s a ton of aftermarket support for Glocks. In fact the $25 HK Pro trigger kit is better than the Apex or GG triggers for the P320 that are more expensive. It was softer recoiling than the P320, and significantly less flippy than the PPQ. This was the actual price at CheaperThanDirt.com at the time of our test. Hk P30 is better than both of those options. How do they shoot: Accuracy? I could gush for hours about the grip. HK’s grip is one of the best anywhere, with interchangeable side panels and backstraps. Subjectively, I thought the VP9 was the nicest shooting of the three. That guy behind the counter at my gun store? HK VP9 vs Glock 17 Concealed Carry. Look, I don’t live in some communist hell-hole where the number of guns I can own is limited. The trigger was very good. The first gun that the HK VP reminded me of was the Walther PPQ mostly due to their similar, outstanding triggers. Also, I liked the paddle magazine release, personally. Which would you buy? This may or may not be possible for you, based on what the ranges near you have available for rent, and how they’re configured. It lets you get the right fit for your hand, even if you shoot better with something asymmetric. Frankly they have given exactly zero fucks about the American market, so Walther vendors are few and far between. HK VP9SK vs Sig P365: Face Off Of The Compact Double Stacks. The compact 9mm P320 has the same magazine capacity as the HK VP9 (15 rounds) but the capacity of the P320 can easily be increased to 17 rounds by using a longer full-size P320 mag in it, or buying the "carry" model grip module and magazine(s). AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own. It fitted my hand reasonably well, but I might have liked to play with the different frame sizes. Firearm Discussion and Resources from AR-15, AK-47, Handguns and more! You can now get 17-round flush-fit magazines for both guns. You can get aftermarket triggers and fire control parts to make the trigger into anything you like, from a heavier duty trigger to a tuned competition trigger. The VP9 handles a variety of bullet weights with ease, and the trigger is smooth and easy to fire. The P320 seems quite heavy for a plastic gun, but the grip is the usual SiG-low. If you want to tinker, get the Glock. VP ergos are better. But really, this is America. How do they shoot: Trigger? The controls are in their usual SiG place, and seem large. No wonderfully cheap Glock or M&P mags here. This time, we decided to try another major debate in the gun world: the HK VP9 vs Walther PPQ. This means that spare parts, accessories, and magazines are the hardest to come by of the three. Switch to Threaded Mode. Neither is ‘They’re all quite good, you can’t go wrong with any of them.’. 9mm is cheap. I probably don’t have anything to worry about here, but there it is. Or mags in the new caliber. Great sights, trigger, trigger reset, awesome grip and grip angle. You have an SP2022, then you already have the best polymer frame SIG. Copyright © 1996-2021 AR15.COM LLC. Or…maybe I suck? Not a dealbreaker, but you should be aware. The VP9 is very similar to the Glock 19 but feels like it was molded for the hand better than the Glock. Be sure to get the capitalization right like I’m doing, or expect a flogging. Yes, I’m going to dwell on it because people won’t shut up about it. VP9 takes top honors here. While it didn’t exactly check all the boxes at the time, HK has come full circle with other polymer models such as the VP9SK to try to perfect the modern striker-fired pistol. love the vp9. Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear. More like shooting a .40 S&W, even though this was a 9mm. hk vp9 The only truly new gun of the three, the VP9 breaks from HKs long line of hammer fired pistols, and is the first striker fired pistol made by HK since the venerable P7 went out of production. Hk VP9 vs Glock 19 vs Sig p320. I have a P320rx, P320 full size in .40cal and a HK VP9. From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm. And, the P320 gets 17 in the mag, not 15. The p320 points more naturally in my hands and iam faster on a timer. I don’t know, I lost track of my metaphors in the aura of Teutonic greatness. Testing and Ranking 5 … Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare ... Sig Sauer P320 XCompact . But that means waiting. With the “subcompact” designatio… -Please Like, Comment & Subscribe-\r\r\r\r\rTwo of the biggest names in firearms faceoff in a whole new, striker fired way! Oh, and you’ll be called a SiG fanboy. Maybe a .22 conversion kit is worth it, if you want a cheap trainer with negligible recoil. Plus, there’s plenty of cachet from being an HK owner. With the SiG, you get the medium grip frame, and you have to go buy the others. Quite a trick. Continue reading. Close. You might think this is cheating in the comparison, but the mag for the P320 is about the same size as that of the VP9 or the PPQ. I WAS set on the Glock 19, but after further thinking I am now back where I started. I don’t shoot 40 or 357 sig enough to want a completely separate gun, but for $400 I now have 3. But hey, when you’ve bought the new frame, new slide, and new barrel to turn your P320 full size into a compact or your 9mm into a .40, you’ve basically bought a new gun in terms of money spent. Of course after all that, you’re still not satisfied. Even HK. I carry a P229 at work so I've been trying to transition out of my love for the "other" germans and get more into Sig, but I've had some real bad experiences with their less than stellar (alright, completely worthless) customer service and history of products not always working the first time around. Maybe it’s fitted tighter or there are some match parts or something. Well I have been wanting to jump on the P320 bandwagon as well. Will fit your hand really well; let’s you have a nice high grip. Which should you buy? They handled the "voluntary upgrade" TERRIBLY. Maybe. I want to buy more guns. That said, I like guns with barbed grips, or barring that, 20 lpi checkering. I have all 4 sig 380’s or tacops full & carry tb. It seemed jumpy, but wasn’t flippy. Also, note that all three of these guns only come with two magazines, which is the bare acceptable minimum these days. Alright, now we come to the main event. Once again, some gubbins to buy. Well, being as this is America, you should buy all three. We’ll look at each pistol, and then do some comparisons. Maybe I should have these stippled. 1 - Vp9 - like the grip, mag drop is a bit strange 2 - Fn 509 tactical - it is big, I like suppressor sights and rmr cut out of the box - will save me $ on rmr related items later 3 - Sig 320 x5 - have not had a chance to shoot it yet I do want to add RMR, light (300x? It is designed for the long-haul, and its simplicity of design and durability will make it a reliable and dependable firearm for years of use. Further, I have some concerns about the durability of the wee inner module (the actual ‘firearm’, legally speaking). AR15.COM is the worldâs largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types. It’s hard to pick a better handgun, but overall, the P320 provides greater versatility, while the VP9 has unique qualities that make it better for certain people. Yes, I’m going to dwell on it because people won’t shut up about it. I prefer a higher grip, or else it would have scored better here. Very smooth. Realistically, you should rent all three, and go home with whichever one you shoot best, preferably with some timed/scored drills. I’ve waited to see if any bugs fell out (they haven’t). Finally, I really, really don’t like the modularity. Pingback: Battle Royale 2: M9 vs P320 - The Soapbox, Pingback: New VP Pistols from HK - The Soapbox. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Battle Royale 2: M9 vs P320 - The Soapbox, The Soapbox Plays: Little Wars (The Battle of Chopinburg House), Wednesday What We’re Reading (Feb. 3, 2021), Wednesday What We’re Reading (Jan. 27, 2021), Fishbreath Prints: the Glockblaster 3D | The Soapbox. So it’s simply a question of how much you like to tinker. # 1 Thing Hk Vp9 Vs Sig Sauer P320 Hk Vp9 Vs Sig Sauer P320 BY Hk Vp9 Vs Sig Sauer P320 in Articles # 1 Thing This is perfect, some prickly molding issues and slight imperfections here and there but for a clone of a Fab reason deposit to be this well made and sturdy for approximately half the price is insanely fine value. We are wringing out the new HK VP9 against the Sig Sauer P320.its going to be close!\r\rThe VP9 is HKs first striker fired gun since the P7, nicknamed the Squeeze Cocker, and the P70, both of which date from the 1970s to 2008. Well, newish. If you want to buy a pistol, add the sights of your choice, and be done, get the HK. The VP9 has the best ergos by far with all the side panels. ... We compare the HK VP9 vs Glock 19.